2008 Historic Preservation Awards

The Historic Preservation Committee of the MVHS Board of Trustees is pleased to announce the winners of the 2008 Historic Preservation Awards. These awards honor those in Mahoning and Trumbull Counties who take an active role in preserving historic buildings, sites and districts.

The Categories and winners are as follows:

Community Revitalization Awards

The Suspension Bridge on Valley Drive in Mill Creek Park in Youngstown

Bulit in 1895, Restored in 2007

This projects efforts included repaving the bridges surface, installation of new channel supports and brackets, along with new timber strip decking and timber plank sidewalks.


The suspension bridge project was completed between June and November 2007. The most recent rehabilitation of the bridge was carried out in 1973 and a concrete pier was constructed under the center of the bridge, and new wide flange steel beams were installed to independently support the bridge deck from the original suspension system.


Prior to the revitalization efforts, the bridge was rated "4P" by the Ohio Department of Transportation, which means the bridge was in poor condition. The bridge suffered from advanced section loss on members, deterioration and spalling. Now the 86 ft. suspension bridge known by different names like "The Cinderella Bridge" and "The Fairytale Bridge," looks as good as new. This bridge was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1976, and was featured in the internationally distributed American Society of Engineers' year 2000 calender.

Moss Ancestral Home in Mineral Ridge
Built in 1843, Restored in 2003

Current owner of the home, Mary Lou Godleski was in search of the home that her great, great grandfather lived when he immigrated to the United States with his family in 1855 from Luxemberg. What she found was a home in complete disrepair, and after large restoration efforts the home is now considered by Architectural restoration classes at Youngstown State University as historical preservation and also historical architecture.

Mary Lou Godleski first set out to find the home in 1990. Upon finding the home which had been condemned by Wethersfield Township Mary Lou struck a deal to purchase the home from the owner whom was inprisoned at the time, and she convinced the local authorities that it was important to save it from being torn down.

The restoration beagan by first tearing out everything that had been recently added to the house. The process also included replacement of floors, ceilings, and windows. Also, the crane and a bake oven from the original kitchen of the house were rebuilt and repaired. Much of this home was restored back to its original form.

Commercial Revitalization Award

Tod Cemetery Mausoleum in Youngstown

Built in 1927, restored 2007

This outstanding example of an early 20th century cemetery facility underwent a major restoration that included new storm sewers and ground water control, asbestos removal, repairing of roof leaks and replacement of original copper roof, flashings, gutters and downspouts. The investment in original materials shows their commitment to community restoration.

The Tod Mausoleum is located on the grounds of the Tod Homestead Cemetery, a National Registry property. The Mausoleum is faced with white Vermont Marble over solid concrete floors, walls and roof. The interior is faced with marble panels, decorative plaster, orante metal work, and Tiffany stained glass windows. The Trustees of the Tod Homestead Cemetery undertook the major restoration project on the occassion of the Mausoleum's 80th year.

MVHS Directors Awards of Achievement

Wick Pollock Inn Sunken Gardens, Youngstown State University

Built 1930, restored 2007

The revitalization of the 1930 Wick Pollock Inn Sunken Gardens, Youngstown State University; This projects efforts were led by members of Youngstown State Universities Student Government Association. More than 40 volunteers contributed over 400 man hours to the efforts which included clearing seven dump truck loads of debris from the garden as well as mulching and maintaining it after the project was completed.

In the spring semester of 2007, the Youngstown State University Student Government Association was approached by a student who had chanced upon an old and forgotten garden near the carriage house of the Wick-Pollock Inn. Since the Inn was closed, the garden had not been touched. So, with their own funds and hard work, the SGA was able to revitalize the garden to become a coveted source of pride for the university.

Organization began in February of 2007 through the collaboration of SGA, YSU groundskeeper Larry Tooker, and Kridler Gardens of Homeworth, Ohio. Mr. Tooker was previously the horticulturalist for Mill Creek Park, and guided SGA through the process from begininng to end.

The hard work and dedication of the students and community members has revitalized a once forgotten garden that Mary Wick Pollock, and even the children of Smoky Hollow walked and played in. Now, the garden can be enjoyed by the thousands of students at YSU as well as members of the public.

The winners will be honored at the Mahoning Valley Historical Society's 133rd Annual Meeting to be held on Tuesday, June 17th in the Christman Room at Stambaugh Auditorium. For more information about the awards and the historical society call 330-743-2589 or visit www.mahoninghistory.org.

Summer Camp Program

History on Stage!














The Mahoning Valley Historical Society presents “History on Stage” a summer camp for children ages 7-12, from June 16-19 2008. The program will be held each of these days from 10 a.m. to 12 p.m. at the Arms Family Museum, 648 Wick Avenue in Youngstown.

Participants will create, produce, direct and star in a mini-drama based on the historic diary of a local pioneer woman. Activities will include historic games, crafts and prop-making.

Family and friends will be invited for a performance on the last day of the camp.

The cost of the camp is $18 for MHVS members and $20 for non-members. This includes a camp t-shirt. To register call 330-743-2589.

BIG NEWS!

Historical Society Purchases Significant Building in Downtown Youngstown to Create A New Visitor Destination


The Mahoning Valley Historical Society has purchased the historic Harry Burt/Ross Radio Building at 325 West Federal Street in downtown Youngstown and is planning to transform the structure into a new Mahoning Valley History Center.

Harry Burt, a famous local confectioner, purchased the building in 1921 and completely remodeled it to operate a candy and ice cream factory, retail store and public dining and assembly rooms. It was at this location that Burt first produced his patented invention: the “Good Humor” ice cream bar on a stick.

After Harry Burt’s death in 1926, his family continued to make and sell candy in the building until 1935, when they sold it to James Ross, founder of the Ross Radio Company. Ross Radio has continuously operated at this location ever since. In 2006 the building was recognized by Parade Magazine and the National Trust for Historic Preservation as one of eleven most historic places in America.

For more than 40 years, the Mahoning Valley Historical Society has been most readily identifiable as the owner of the Arms Family Museum of Local History, located at 648 Wick Avenue in Youngstown in the former residence of Olive F.A. and Wilford P. Arms. The 1905 Arts and Crafts-style mansion and garage buildings function as a historic house, regional history museum and archives facility.

"The Arms residence is the most significant artifact in our collection and it is our responsibility to care for it,” says Historical Society Executive Director H. William (Bill) Lawson. “But, it is also our responsibility to present the entire history of the Valley. The residence buildings were designed to be a private home, not a museum, and we are challenged every time we develop a new exhibit. Because of space limitations, we are unable to display the vast majority of our collections; we have little space for educational programs; and our ability to care for the collections is compromised because we have to store most of our artifacts away from the museum in spaces with inadequate climate control.”

To better meet the needs of the community, Historical Society’s Board and staff members carefully studied several locations in Youngstown’s central area before deciding in 2007 that the Burt Building was the ideal location in which to create the new Mahoning Valley History Center. “This site offers so much,” states Lawson.

“First, it is a historic structure. And, with over 22,000 square feet of available interior space, it is a great facility to enhance the level of service we provide to the residents of the Valley.” He adds, "Its location downtown is also important and will hopefully stimulate further redevelopment of the city’s core.”

The Historical Society is currently in a quiet fundraising phase to secure the dollars needed to rehabilitate and adapt the structure. When complete, the new History Center will:

· Feature interactive, inclusive exhibits that relate to all people who live in the Mahoning Valley, dedicated education space and research facilities in a state-of-the-art visitor destination

· Improve collections management by consolidating the artifacts into on-site, climate-controlled storage and conservation facilities

· Broaden the Historical Society’s appeal by hosting major traveling exhibitions, expanded on-site education programs, and off-site outreach for all interest levels

· Offer an exciting new downtown venue for cultural and community activities, and public and private gatherings for groups of all sizes

· Relieve the pressures currently being placed on the Arms Family Museum, and focus on interpreting this historic house and landscape and exhibiting the Historical Society’s exceptional decorative arts collection.

A national fundraising firm completed a Leadership Planning Study and recommended moving forward with a capital and endowment campaign to finance the project. An initial 10-month campaign process will include cultivating and enlisting campaign leaders and volunteers and the solicitation of gifts from area businesses, corporations, foundations, and individuals.

“Combined with the Historical Society’s valuable collections, this campaign will create a first-class history center for residents of the Mahoning Valley and beyond,” said Board President C. Reid Schmutz in announcing the plans. “In a sense, the new facility will become a ‘family learning center’ where generations of the past will meet generations of the future to learn about the Valley’s heritage.”

“This project represents a substantial investment of private funds in downtown Youngstown, and will result in an additional arts and entertainment anchor for our revitalized central business district” said Youngstown Mayor Jay Williams. He further states “I applaud and support the Mahoning Valley Historical Society’s commitment to address current operational challenges and to reach out to the broader community by developing a new regional History Center.”

Founded in 1875 and incorporated in 1909, The Mahoning Valley Historical Society educates and promotes an interest in the history of the Mahoning Valley by collecting, preserving, and developing material representative of the people who have inhabited the region. For more information about the Historical Society, details about the plans for the Burt Building, or to schedule a tour, call 330-743-2589.

History to Go - Irish in the Valley

In the Mahoning Valley Historical Society’s ongoing mission to provide an opportunity for the community to discover local history, the Young Leaders Advisory Board is pleased to announce the next event in the popular History to Go lecture series: Irish in the Valley.

Join the Mahoning Valley Historical Society on Monday, March 10th at 6:30 p.m. at St. Patrick’s Catholic Church, 1410 Oak Hill Ave. in Youngstown, for a presentation on the rich history of the Irish in the Mahoning Valley by Sally Murphy Pallante of The Irish American Archival Society.

This free event is partnered by St. Patrick’s Catholic Church and underwritten by: Rulli Bros.

For further information please phone the MVHS at 330-743-2589 or e-mail at: mvhs@mahoninghistory.org

You Can Help!

One of the more frequent requests in the MVHS Archives is for images of national politicians that have made campaign stops in the Valley.

Here's how you can help:

If you attended any of the events hosted by Senators Clinton or Obama, or any other event related to their campaign, and have pictures, please consider donating a set of prints to the archives.

One request:

Prints produced at a photo lab (drug stores, photo shops, and online services) are best for long term preservation. Prints produced on ink-jet or home photo printers are not as stable, and could flake and fade over time.

For more information on donating items to MVHS please don't hesitate to contact the staff!

Please help the Mahoning Valley Historical Society fufill its mission of collecting and preserving your histoy - remember, these are your stories, your experiences, your history!

Image is of Franklin D. Roosevelt making a stop in downtown Youngstown.

The First Ice Cream Wagon

Bill Dwyre of the Los Angeles Times provides this story on Kelly Pavlik.
If Youngstown is a "cruddy" place, it is also a place of pride for Pavlik.
"The first ice cream wagon was in Youngstown, Ohio," he says. "You can Google it."

That's exactly right Kelly, the first ice cream wagon was developed by Harry Burt; here is the story!

The Significance of Harry Burt and "Good Humor" Bars

“Good Humor Suckers” grew to be one of the great icons of American summers of the urban and suburban mid-twentieth century. From the mid-1920s to the mid-1970s, the white refrigerator truck announced by a ringing bell, the white uniformed driver, the pleading with parents for money to buy an ice cream bar, and the gathering of neighborhood children became important, nostalgic memories for several generations of residents of a large area of the United States. Harry Burt, the Youngstown confectionery who strived to make the most delicious candy and ice cream, created the treat, patented the process of production and the machinery for its making, and created the unusual system for its distribution.




History of the Burt Confectionery & Creation of the "Good Humor" Bar

In downtown Youngstown between 1893 and 1922, Harry B. Burt (1875-1926) worked as a confectioner who produced candy, then added ice cream, soda fountain and grill to his store, expanding his business to include a bakery and restaurant, finally adding twelve refrigerator trucks to distribute Good Humor bars to Mahoning Valley and Youngstown city neighborhoods. All these successes he accomplished during the decades of Youngstown’s greatest social, commercial and industrial expansion.

Read More...

Award Winning Documentation

Mahoning Valley Historical Society’s Arms Family Museum is documented; Drawings win national award

The Mahoning Valley Historical Society is proud to announce that architecture students from Kent State University have won the national Charles E. Peterson prize for their work in documenting the former Olive and Wilford Arms residence, now the Arms Family Museum of Local History, for the National Park Service’s Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS).

The Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) for Greystone is the first one to be completed in Mahoning County. Funding for the project was provided by The Walter F. and Caroline H. Watson Foundation.

Students of Elizabeth Corbin Murphy, FAIA, a Principal in the firm of Chambers, Murphy and Burge Restoration Architects, Ltd., of Akron, Ohio, and an Adjunct Professor at Kent State University’s College of Architecture and Environment Design, worked on the Arms House HABS project over the course of the 2006-2007 academic years. They researched original construction documents, sketches and photographs from various eras in the site’s history with assistance from the MVHS staff; they field measured the house inside and out, and measured the property for elevations and major historic landscape features.

The Students produced measured drawings of the site with plans and elevations of the historic buildings it contains according to United States Department of the Interior, National Park Service’s specifications for HABS submissions; submitted the drawings and other required documents to the National Park Service for acceptance into the HABS collection at the Library of Congress, and provided copies of the same for the MVHS archives collection.

The project was also submitted for The Charles E. Peterson Prize, which annually recognizes the best set of measured drawings prepared to HABS standards and donated to HABS by students. The prize honors Charles E. Peterson, FAIA, founder of the HABS program, and is intended to increase awareness, knowledge, and appreciation of historic buildings throughout the United States while adding to the permanent HABS collection of measured drawings at the Library of Congress. To date, more than 2,000 students from 68 colleges and universities have participated by completing more than 500 entries and almost 5,000 sheets of measured drawings. The Arms House project received first place honors and students accepted the award at a ceremony in New Orleans, LA. They received a $3,000 cash prize. View a slideshow of the 2007 award winners. (The images take a few minutes to load.)


The Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS), the nation's first federal preservation program, began in 1933 to document America's architectural heritage. According to the Library of Congress American Memory website, “the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) and the Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) collections are among the largest and most heavily used in the Prints and Photographs Division of the Library of Congress. The collections document achievements in architecture, engineering, and design in the United States and its territories through a comprehensive range of building types and engineering technologies. All of the documents in the HABS collection are available free of copyright restrictions.

Staff from MVHS attended a presentation at Kent State by Mark Schara, an architect with HABS that outlined the significance of the program, and showed some of the recent projects. The drawings of the Arms house produced by the students were on display as an encouragement for architecture students to apply for the HABS summer programs.

MVHS Executive Director Bill Lawson (far right) congratulates the Kent State students on a job well done. With Mark Schara (far left) and Elizabeth Corbin Murphy (second from left).

Read the Youngstown Vindicator article here.